Dan vs Fred

Postby **Aletheia Dolorosa** » Wed Jul 23, 2003 1:02 am

I liked these books almost as much as HDM
But it was so sad when Fred died...except for that I liked the third one the best...and i felt guilty because I liked Dan Goldberg more than fred...but I also worked out who it was before the end as well. It's amazing how different the two series were - just shows how great PP is as an author - versatility!!!

but i didn't like the Tin princess nearly so much.

and most of my friends, who I leant HDM to, and then Sally Lockhart, didn't like Sally Lockhart at all!!!
strange ppl

Shalom, Salaam and other assorted et ceteras

Kyrillion · Postby **Kyrillion** » Fri Oct 10, 2003 12:07 am

I haven't read the Tin Princess, but I thought I might like it, cause I liked that kid (Adelle? something like that) from The Ruby in The Smoke.

On Dan/Fred - I prefferred Dan too.

Starshade · Postby **Starshade** » Fri Oct 10, 2003 10:49 am

Fred was cool.
It shouldn't have been so...

Postby **Aletheia Dolorosa** » Tue Oct 14, 2003 2:10 am

NOt true...Fred was cool, but I had to pretend he didn't exist to be happy in the next book.... I'm so pathetic, but I belief in true love...and how can it exist twice? (ie sally and fred, then sally and dan)

Hephaestion · Postby **Hephaestion** » Fri Oct 22, 2004 12:41 pm

amen to that Aletheia - I be in the midst of a most unfair ture love and I know how damned permanent it is.

I can't say I've read any Big Phil work except HDM which is my favourite book in all the cosmos.

Postby **Aletheia Dolorosa** » Wed Oct 27, 2004 12:43 am

As one who is/was in the same situation for the past four years, I sympathise.

Life should mirror 'the world between the pages', it's much more logical there!

(and I agree with you...HDM forever: my favourite book/series since 1997!)

Alewyn · Postby **Alewyn** » Mon Nov 14, 2005 12:08 am

I had to keep blocking Fred out during TIW. Terribly sad about his death. I read his death during a school concert (not good) and named my flute Frederick Garland in honor of Fred.
Fred/Dan...Well Dan is definitely more awesome (his speech when they were going to attack the Jewish baker's building, to die for!), but I love Fred more. Fred just was with Sally more and they had the 2 book build up to their love. Which one is better? I have no idea.

Ian · Postby **Ian** » Mon Nov 14, 2005 1:50 am

Fred was a first love, which was nice. Dan was far more interesting. Dan it is.

Postby **Aletheia Dolorosa** » Tue Nov 15, 2005 11:39 pm

I just reread the whole series a few days ago (when I should have been studying for uni exams, of course!) and was reminded of the awesomeness of that speech Dan made at the bakers to stop the mob attacking the Jewish houses. For that, I'd have to make it Dan. It's just brilliant!!!! Sums up my political views perfectly.
But Fred's so cool.... Oh, how do you decide????

Kyrillion · Postby **Kyrillion** » Wed Nov 16, 2005 9:39 pm

I think The Tiger... is my favourite Sally Lockhart.

And I always like a love story where the falling for the romantic lead goes hand in hand with a shift in personal philosophy.

Dan vs Fred

Dan vs Fred

Go Dan!!!!!!!!!

Sympathy

that speech!

Who is online